Hi All
I have 6 fonera stations (openwrt 8.09 + batman) I would like to turn them on and check system stability and performance for some time Can you address me to a good way to test and log system performance/stability?
Thnaks Marco
P.S. I am available to help batman comunity with specific tests if any
Hi Marco!
You could introduce massive traffic from/to as many nodes as possible and keep them running for a long time. When I did so with Ubiquiti Nanostations I found that the CPU power was too low to saturate the network by downloading from /dev/zero from one node to /dev/null on another node. (I achieved only ~ 800 kByte/sec on a single hop link - rather than 3.3MByte/sec!) I have tried this with netcat, http, ftp, iperf. So I connected a laptop to the LAN port of the NS2 and downloaded from the laptop via the mesh into another laptop. Which seems to be highly impractical in your case.
Bear in mind that depending on the version of your Foneras you are rather going to learn about the instability of the hardware or drivers in ad-hoc mode. Earlier versions of the Fonera have hardware stability issues.
Recent versions of Kamikaze trunk seem to have stability issues in the Madwifi driver again - it seems like the stuck beacon problem is back, I have seen messages in dmesg that seem to indicate this :-(
Please check the uptime of the nodes during your tests - in case of a malfunction the watchdog will silently reboot. Which is what happened to me using a DIR-300 every one to three days.
For me I could fix the problem - I'm exclusively using mesh networking for all my IT communication needs 24/7 - why would I want to use wireless point-to-multipoint networking if I can have multipoint-to-multipoint wireless networking ;-) - by switching to ahdemo mode. If you are not using ahdemo, make sure you use ad-hoc mode with the nosbeacon aka swmerge option.
That said I prefer testing in a productive environment - of course not all users are willing to bear a experimental network as their productive environment ;-) But if their connectivity doesn't work in the long run you as the admin will quickly get to know about it ;-)
Starting a little community mesh network is a great experiment on all kinds of levels, including the social non-OSI Layer 8! And you'll learn about technical problems you are never going to meet in your lab - because you'll see other drivers/devices in a heterogeneous environment trying to connect, introducing noise and trying to create IBSS-ID splits.
From the protocol side we are keen on getting reports about the functionality and usability, CPU load, memory consumption, protocol overhead. However a mesh with 6 nodes is not pushing things to the limit for the Batman protocol (well, you can decrease the OGM interval to a much smaller value than 1 second!). But it will help developers to find bugs in recent code changes if you happen to test new versions.
Cheers, Elektra
I have 6 fonera stations (openwrt 8.09 + batman) I would like to turn them on and check system stability and performance for some time Can you address me to a good way to test and log system performance/stability?
Thnaks Marco
P.S. I am available to help batman comunity with specific tests if any.
Hi Elektra
Thank you for your great support Now I have 4 station on and connected through batman
Following your tips I did setup a netcat data exchange
I had very few time to work on this project, so my main task till now was to turn on and connect the more station I can In the next days I would like to check if they are still there (without watchdog reboot in the meantime) and are still transferring data
I hope I can achieve a serious test bench in the near future - I will be back with better news
Thanks Cheers Marco
elektra wrote:
Hi Marco!
You could introduce massive traffic from/to as many nodes as possible and keep them running for a long time. When I did so with Ubiquiti Nanostations I found that the CPU power was too low to saturate the network by downloading from /dev/zero from one node to /dev/null on another node. (I achieved only ~ 800 kByte/sec on a single hop link - rather than 3.3MByte/sec!) I have tried this with netcat, http, ftp, iperf. So I connected a laptop to the LAN port of the NS2 and downloaded from the laptop via the mesh into another laptop. Which seems to be highly impractical in your case.
Bear in mind that depending on the version of your Foneras you are rather going to learn about the instability of the hardware or drivers in ad-hoc mode. Earlier versions of the Fonera have hardware stability issues.
Recent versions of Kamikaze trunk seem to have stability issues in the Madwifi driver again - it seems like the stuck beacon problem is back, I have seen messages in dmesg that seem to indicate this :-(
Please check the uptime of the nodes during your tests - in case of a malfunction the watchdog will silently reboot. Which is what happened to me using a DIR-300 every one to three days.
For me I could fix the problem - I'm exclusively using mesh networking for all my IT communication needs 24/7 - why would I want to use wireless point-to-multipoint networking if I can have multipoint-to-multipoint wireless networking ;-) - by switching to ahdemo mode. If you are not using ahdemo, make sure you use ad-hoc mode with the nosbeacon aka swmerge option.
That said I prefer testing in a productive environment - of course not all users are willing to bear a experimental network as their productive environment ;-) But if their connectivity doesn't work in the long run you as the admin will quickly get to know about it ;-)
Starting a little community mesh network is a great experiment on all kinds of levels, including the social non-OSI Layer 8! And you'll learn about technical problems you are never going to meet in your lab
- because you'll see other drivers/devices in a heterogeneous
environment trying to connect, introducing noise and trying to create IBSS-ID splits.
From the protocol side we are keen on getting reports about the functionality and usability, CPU load, memory consumption, protocol overhead. However a mesh with 6 nodes is not pushing things to the limit for the Batman protocol (well, you can decrease the OGM interval to a much smaller value than 1 second!). But it will help developers to find bugs in recent code changes if you happen to test new versions.
Cheers, Elektra
b.a.t.m.a.n@lists.open-mesh.org
-
elektra -
Marco Tozzini -
marco tozzini