On Sun, 2011-12-04 at 22:18 +0000, Russell King - ARM Linux wrote:
.../...
And really, I believe it would be a good cleanup if all the standard definitions for atomic64 ops (like atomic64_add_negative) were also defined in include/linux/atomic.h rather than individually in every atomic*.h header throughout the kernel source, except where an arch wants to explicitly override it. Yet again, virtually all architectures define these in exactly the same way.
We have more than enough code in arch/ for any architecture to worry about, we don't need schemes to add more when there's simple and practical solutions to avoiding doing so if the right design were chosen (preferably from the outset.)
So, I'm not going to offer my ack for a change which I don't believe is the correct approach.
I agree with Russell, his approach is a lot easier to maintain long run, we should even consider converting existing definitions.
Cheers, Ben.